View Full Version : Healing ADD (Amen)


Tara
03-07-03, 10:57 PM
<table border="0" width="475" align="Center"> <tbody> <tr><td width=27%><font color="#440066" face="comic sans ms"><a href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0425183270/ref%3Dnosim/addforums-20/" target="_blank"><img src="http://livingwithadd.com/healing6.jpg" width="94" height="140" border="0" alt="Healing ADD: The Breakthrough Program That Allows You to See and Heal the Six Types of ADD">
</a>
</font></td>
<td><font face="comic sans ms" size="3" color="#440066">This book has many answers to ADD and different types of ADD. It offers suggestions to help manage the different types of ADD. It suggests that medications,nutritional approaches, supplements, etc. all work differently for each type of ADD. <B>(2002)</B></font></td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<center><B>Browse at Amazon<BR><font color="#440066" face="comic sans ms"><a href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0425183270/ref%3Dnosim/addforums-20/" target="_blank">(US)</A><a href="http://www.amazon.ca/exec/obidos/ASIN/0425183270/ref%3Dnosim/livingwitha0c-20/" target="_blank">(Canada)</A><a href="http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/0425183270/ref%3Dnosim/livingwithadd-21" target="_blank">(UK)</A>

unreal33
05-15-03, 01:23 AM
I think this book relies too heavily on the SPECT imaging stuff, and less on the other science surrounding ADD. Most of the rest of the book is stuff you can read elsewhere.

Tara
05-15-03, 01:30 AM
Where else do you suggest to find the info in this book? I have over 40 AD/HD books in my library and I found the info in this book to be unique.

unreal33
05-15-03, 01:41 AM
Oh, it's certainly unique as far as the brain imaging information. But as for the connection to the amino acid deficiencies, that's been in other medical journals and books on ADHD, including some you can find at various health food/nutritional supplement stores... and the nutritional info is all also in a book specifically on nutrition and ADHD that I saw in the bookstore last year. But I'll grant you, much of the info on brain imaging and the various subtypes of ADHD are unique. Not saying it was a bad book, just that I kind of expected more from the title "Healing ADD."

rogerj1
06-11-03, 01:44 AM
This is the only book I've read thoroughly about ADD. Am I missing something by not reading other books?

Tara
06-11-03, 02:12 AM
I think it's a good idea to read as many AD/HD books as possible.

There are many different theories and points of view of AD/HD and learning about them help you form your own idea as to what you think AD/HD is.

waywardclam
08-15-03, 03:08 PM
By Dr. Daniel G. Amen of the Amen Clinic, also wrote Change Your Brain, Change Your Life.

I am 80% through this book and it is very clinical but I am finding it very interesting. Does anybody here know anything about the book or about Dr. Amen or the Amen Clinic? He sounds fantastic from the perspective of his own book, but I would be interested in hearing an outside opinion.

It's also fascinating to hear about his subtypes of ADD that he recognizes... an entirely new paradigm to me of looking at the condition...

I could summarize some of his ideas here if people are interested.

Slowpoke
08-18-03, 11:10 AM
I don`t mean to be disrespectful to everyone who supports this, but I did the online questionnaire and printed it out. When I took it to show my doctors, I got the same general response: it means absolutely nothing, the results useless... even from the doctor who was an AD/HD specialist... I was dissapointed, but am intrigued as to why it would be that this is not recognized more...?

waywardclam
08-18-03, 11:27 AM
Ooops thanks for moving my post into this thread... should have done more research as to whether it had been discussed already :D :D :D

Everything I have ever been told is that questionnaires are not very useful in the diagnosis of ADD, and the anecdotal evidence from self, parents, spouse, teachers, family, etc. is more important.

As to why your doctor doesn't take it seriously... I would immediately fear that your doctor might be one of those people who doesn't take ADD seriously, and believes we are all people who just need to "pull our socks up" or something like that...

In the end though, it doesn't matter, does it? If your doctor wants to use a different method to diagnose you, you can go ahead and try your doctor's method, right? And if you don't like that, you can always go find another doctor. The medical profession seems to be very fragmented as to how they want to handle ADD. :(

MightyMouse
08-19-03, 01:15 PM
This book is on the top of my "need to read list" for any AD/HD patients I have. I loved this book. Personally - and I understand I am in the minority here - I loved the clinical format and details of the book. I keep a copy handy in my home office and eventually when I have a "work" office I wil have another copy there.

DSCH
09-01-03, 02:03 PM
I believe Dr. Amen should be commended for his clinical work with brain imaging and breaking down the catch-all that is ADD/ADHD into more specific subtypes. His exact conclusions are one thing, the general direction he is pointing out to psychiatry and psychology is another. Psychiatry and psychology without physical and quantitative diagnostics of brain and body function is shooting blind.

BadHire
04-26-04, 06:14 PM
eh ... I don't know about this book.

a) It seems like another "oh wow, only Doctor xxxx really understands what's going on" books. Every complicated condition seems to require one of these.

b) The book seems to serve largely as an advertisement for his clinics.

c) Sure, the book has some good info, but doesn't really cover any new ground. Plus, if his SPECT imaging stuff is so amazing and important, why don't we see others trying to replicate and add to his results?

d) And what's up with Demi Moore on the back cover recommending the book???? Eeek!

gabriela
06-14-04, 05:29 AM
i'm going to bring dr amen's book "healing add" to my next doctor's appointment. it'll be interesting to hear what *her* opinion on this spect stuff is!
:D
theories are almost always fun, i think!
:D :yin-yang:

Dissident
07-05-04, 10:12 AM
I just picked this up the other day as my first book on ADD. I'm most of the way through it and it seems pretty helpful and rather encouraging as well. I may get some of my family to have a look at it when I'm finished.

gabriela
07-10-04, 12:28 PM
Personally - and I understand I am in the minority here - I loved the clinical format and details of the book.
me too, although i realise i need to learn a lot more about neuroanatomy in order to fully understand it - in fact i'm going to ask my doctor (who's a psychiatrist specializing in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder) if she has a book on this subject to lend me the next time i see her!
:)
it's kinda "weird"; i've *"always"* been fascinated by "the brain" - i can still remember how *interested* and absolutely *amazed* i was when, as a child, i watched this (i believe it was from bbc) program about patients with severe epilepsy who, in order to stop them from having so many disabling seizures, underwent callosalectomies (cutting of the nerve bands in the corpus callosum)!
(*not* what you'd call your typical childrens' program!;-)

i found it fascinating how, after the surgery, these patients lost their coordination (in varying degrees), and how they could *see* an object, yet be unable to *name* it...
:confused:
little did i know that - many years later - the doctors would tell me i'm one of the few people who're born with a "natural" callosalectomy...

perlguy
07-10-04, 07:14 PM
My question, has anyone here been "healed" of their ADD?

gabriela
07-11-04, 03:50 PM
don't know about that, but i do think that most of us in here wouldn't want to be "cured", if it was possible...
i started a poll related to your post a while back - "*are* you, or do you *have* adhd/add?"

here's a link to that poll:

http://www.addforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=7648

when i started the poll, i saw my adhd/add as a "disorder", and i *still* do, but i think i've now begun seeing the positive sides of my adhd/add: i'm creative, optimistic and a *great* brainstormer!
:D
although i *do* take medication (concerta) for the "downsides" of my adhd/add, i wouldn't want to be without it!
:)

auntchris
02-07-05, 02:56 AM
thanks tara for the info on the test which i took and the book Healing ADD. auntchris

abre los ojos
02-07-05, 08:15 AM
Dr. Amen does have a little bit of a snakeoiler in him, but his clinical work seems to be worth take note of. He doesn't "rely" on spects. He says himself in the books that spects are not necessary, and that a personal history is a more important tool for diagnosing ADD. I have overfocus ADD, and reading his clinical experience with this type was like reading my own biography. He was right on target with his conclusion that stimulants alone make this type worse, while offering solutions that do work. His work pinpointed for me what my problem had been all my life, something the other stack of books on ADD failed to do. His profile and categorization concerning over-focus ADD alone is novel as well as groundbreaking.

carbonrod
02-16-05, 09:30 PM
This was the firsxt book on ADD that i have had the chance to read. I liked it quite a bit. I don't have anything else to compare it to, but it definitely helped me gain alot of insight into my ADD. Overall though, "Healing ADD" functions quite well as a general ADD resource, but as a "Healing Tool" it really is just going to be a starting point for me, and I intend to move on to other books that go into more detail about organizing (which I suck at), study habits for ADD'ers (Again not too good at those either) and just overall approaches to thriving with ADD.