View Full Version : You and the and the psychiatrist: who thinks what?

10-29-07, 06:08 PM
ADHD And Psychiatry: One Third Of Visits Don't Address Parents' Greatest Concerns

Submitted by News Account ( on 25 October 2007 - 11:00pm. Psychiatry (
According to a small-scale, in-office, observational study, psychiatrists and parents have significantly different perceptions of the importance of pediatric ADHD and psychiatric comorbidities, particularly regarding the patients’ most concerning behavior.

The study, which utilized accepted sociolinguistic methodologies to evaluate the tone, content and structure of in-office visits, was presented recently at the 20th annual U.S. Psychiatric and Mental Health Congress (USPMHC).

“We found that among the psychiatrists and parents studied, 78 percent provided different responses when asked about the patient’s ‘most concerning behavior,’” said Robert Findling, M.D., lead author and professor of psychiatry at Case Western Reserve University and director of the division of child and adolescent psychiatry at University Hospitals Case Medical Center. “There was a notable incidence of psychiatrist/parent misalignment regarding the patients’ most concerning behaviors, including aggression and defiance.”

The study, designed to capture naturally occurring conversations between psychiatrists, patients with ADHD and their parents, consisted of eleven psychiatrists, thirty-two child and adolescent ADHD patients and their parents.

Half of the patients were younger than 13 years old, and the majority fulfilled the criteria of “complicated ADHD,” which was defined in the study as a patient “having or suspected to have one or more psychiatric comorbidities.” Physicians classified 81 percent of patients as having one or more psychiatric comorbidities/learning disabilities. The most common comorbidities greater than 20 percent included: depression (46 percent), oppositional defiant disorder (42 percent), anxiety (38 percent), learning disabilities (35 percent) and bipolar disorder (23 percent).

In post-visit interviews, parents most often reported concern about aggression and defiance; however, these behaviors that parents reported as “most concerning” post-visit were unaddressed in one-third of the visits.

“These results indicate psychiatrists can adopt several techniques to improve in-office communication about complicated ADHD, including structuring visits, so that all voices are heard, discussing comorbidities using language that is more comprehensible to parents, and eliciting parents’ expectations at the initiation of treatment,” said Dr. Findling. “By focusing on how time is spent and what types of questions are asked of parents and patients, this can lead to successful expectation-setting with both parents and patients. As a result, psychiatrists can have better in-office discussions about ADHD as well as improved treatment of patients suffering from complicated ADHD.”

- Porter Novelli

10-29-07, 08:49 PM
Child psychiatry is tricky i hear.

Sometimes the family or parenting is part of the problem. (Just like lazy parents blame the 'teacher' when "johnny can't read'.)

Sometimes the child is the symptom bearer of the family's greater ecosystem of problems. (And many family problems are multi-generational too.)

Sounds like these are also communication problems, eh? (As the Article's last Paragraph says.)

Take a shopping list of questions, I say.

10-29-07, 09:13 PM
I agree. Family support systems is a huge part in all this. I always go into doctors appointments with a list of questions I have. Never see a doctor "blind" because if you don't ask the right questions, you will never get all the answers to your conditions.